Good day to you lovacars ji,
If you use one of the 50 odd dasha systems, I feel any event can be justified in any chart.
You are absolutely right. we can explain every event using the 50 odd dasha systems. But what we are doing here is just a post Mortem. When this horoscope came to me the last thing I would have seen is death. My guru always say's that the first thing you should do when you get a horoscope for marriage is to see if the native has "Ayushya". I failed to see this aspect when I matched the horoscope's. After all who would expect a healthy girl to die at the age of 24 ? It's very uncommon, am I right ?
As far as dasha Scheme's go, I chose Astottari because the horoscope fit both the criteria given for it's applicability. It's the next widely used dasha system after Vimshottari. If Vimshottari is applied I fail to find any valid reason for Shani to kill the girl when he is also the lagna lord and was posited in the 9th house in Gochara. He could have killed her when he was in the 8th In Leo, but he did not, so why would he do it when he came to the 9th ?
Rahu / Shani / Shukra was in operation at the time of her death. Rahu has all the time in the world to kill her, but he did not. Shani was in the 8th from 2007 onwards but he did not kill her, so why now ? Rahu was in the lagna in 2008/9 , he should have killed her then, But she was busy planning her marriage. So there is a loop hole we need to cover up.
Now look at the Ashtotarri dasha Scheme, she saw Shukra / Ravi /Chandra MD's. As you rightly pointed out Ravi could have taken her. but see the dictum I have mentioned for death to occur. My guru is very clear on this dictum " For death to occur there must be a association of the 6th lord, the 8th lord, the Maraka lord and the Badaka lord." . There is another dictum that is used widely " For Makara Lagna Ravi does not get "Astamadipathya dosha". Meaning Ravi will not act like the 8th lord in his dasha
. I being the pessimest do not subscribe to the last dictum, But in this case it seems to have worked wonders.
Look at Chandra. He is the Maraka, was in the Maraka sthana at the time of death, Is in the 8th lord's Nakshatra in the rashi chart, Budha is the 6th lord in debilitation. Budha is in the lagna lord's Rashi. here starts the trouble. At the time of death the running dasha was Chandra / Budha / budha / budha. Guru the culprit is in the 2nd in the rashi chart in a maraka place and is associated with Budha because Budha is in Guru's rashi. The girl died of a disease. She had a failed liver. I thing Ashtottari explains these events best.
For death to occur there must be a association of the 6th lord, the 8th lord, the Maraka lord and the Badaka lord."
At the time of death Kuja (Natal Badaka lord) was in the natal 8th house, 8th lord was with the natal 6th lord in the natal 6th. Kuja the badaka lord was aspecting the Maraka lord Chandra at the time of death. Note chandra is at 0deg20 in the 2nd house in Gochara. hence there is some truth to the dictum.
Trust this helps,
Through hard work and spiritual practices, a person gets honor and dignity. The lazy one who puts in no efforts is like a fool who allows salt to be spilled on the wounds of his misfortunes. The idler depending only on fate, achieves nothing. - K.N.Rao ji