Madam,
I know rahu aspects fifth using jaimini angle. It is only a mild affliction and not the cause of the problem. I read the original email and I clearly know the problem. What interested me the karkataka lagna chart. My BIL's wife went through 9 mis-carriages and both have same lagna (karkataka) and fifth lord is exalted in 7th house. At 42 and 41 there are still childless (they adapted a girl 8 yrs back).
Husbands chart is vrishabha lagna with worst malefic Jupiter controlling mercury (5L) and sun. It does not matter if there is an exchange or Jupiter is a natural benefic. I give more importance to lordship. Take a look at A1 and A5 and see the condition of Sun. Sun is gnati karaka in jaimini (I do only 7 karakas and not 8 as others do). See running chara dasa of Dhanu and sun goes to 12th. If you know KP astrology. See 5th lord house cusp Sun and its sublord, see mercury nakshatra swami and sub lord. All this suggests to me that his chart is more problematic than hers. It takes two to tango. In many childless couples - it is the past karma (luck, chance or call it what ever) that brought them together to go through karma phala.
My opinion (we may agree to disagree and move on).
I don't believe in rahu aspects (shadowy planet), this theory of MKS, 8 karakas. Most of the time it does not work. Take a look at GW Bush's chart and see how many planets are in MKS and nothing happened. Jupiter is in third H in worst place?? No way. His father was another president, he has had multiple younger siblings.. There is a big difference between text book astrology and practical experience .I arrive at a composite sketch using Jaimini, arudha pada, parashari (with rasi , nakshatra, navamsa and d chart as needed), KP astrology, transits, running dasha to make a call.
In this case husband's chart shows more affliction when it comes to seeing progeny matters (another hint: see his 11th house cusp lord). It does not matter if you agree or not. I do not consider astrology as a science. Upto the point of casting the chart and making calculations, it is math. After this point people (astrologers) differ in the way they interpret, the way they predict. It involves, experience, practical intuition, prayer, spiritual strength, knowledge of various systems.
anuradha wrote:[list=][/list]
M.S.Sharma
PS: I do not take Rahu aspects as some other astrologers do. I do not think, rahu is an issue in your chart at all.[/quote
Sharmaji,
Even if you do not take the asecpect of Rahu, Rahu is in Cancer in Lagna, aspecting the 5H[ Scorpio] from Jaimini angle , so the 5H is under the influence of Rahu.
1st miscarriage
Unexpected heavy bleeding on 13th May 2011 when I was 7 weeks and 3 days pregnant. Only the previous day, the ultrasound had shown a good formation. No real cause located. Termed as a random event. My uterus is bicornuate (heart shaped) - but the baby was too small at this time to be affected by that.
I had my D&C on 27th May after much harassment from money hungry doctors.
2nd miscarriage
Ultrasound on 14th november 2011 showed a healthy heartbeat. Next ultrasound on 30th Nov at 11 and 1/2 weeks pregnancy showed a formation defect called aminiotic band syndrome. something rare and randon. Again, no reason in particular why this happens. Definitely not related to my bicornuate uterus. I had my D&C on 7th Dec.
This above information is suggesting , where is the problem. If husband has a problem there would be no conception.
2. Husband chart:
Getting taurus lagna, sun dasha running. severely afflicted 5th lord
Husband's 5L is misplaced a bit in 6H, with 8L and 11L, but with the most benefice Jupiter, without any aspect or association of malefic. Jupiter as 8L in exchange with 6L Venus. Both Venus and Jupiter are pure, without any malefic aspect or association. In D-7, 5L Mercury is in Lagna aspecting by LL Saturn and 6L Moon.
Aspect of Rahu is a controversial subject , some classical supports it and some do not. But it does not mean that you conclude that Rahu has no role. Regards
Chaos (6,8,12) = Cash for astrologers, gemstone sellers, consultants, bankruptcy lawyers, doctors and investors + परोपदेषा काले सर्वे व्यास पराशरः