Moderator: ChandraLagna
astrokinghyd wrote:Example1:
Planet Jupiter - Natural Benefic - plus
Sign - Pisces - Own Sign - plus
House 11th House - favourable - plus
Retrograde - yes - minus
Conclusion: plus x plus x plus x minus = minus
Therefore, Retrograde Jupiter in Pisces in 11th house is bad.
Example2:
Planet saturn - Natural Malefic - minus
Sign - Libra - Exalted - plus
House 5th House - unfavourable - minus
Conclusion: minus x plus x minus = plus
Therefore, a non-retrograde exalted saturn in 5th house is good.
astrokinghyd wrote:The following superceeds all the above logic:
1.All vargottams are good (even debilitated vargottams)
2. Any planet debilitated in navamsa is finally bad
umaabirami wrote:4th lord Sun is debiliated in 6th in Libra and it is Vargottama.
That means (a) is minus as it is natural malefic (b) is minus as it is debiliated (c) is plus as it is natural malefic in dusta house. Final result is plus so good eventough debiliated Vargottama?
basab wrote: now let me give an example and apply your method and my method. i think it will prove my point.
example1(your method)
Planet Saturn - Natural Malefic - minus
Sign - Libra - Exaltation Sign - plus
House 10th house - favourable - plus
Retrograde - no - so not considering it as a factor as you have said.
Conclusion: minus x plus x plus = minus
Therefore, Saturn in Libra in 10th house is bad.
example1(my method)
Planet Saturn - Natural Malefic - minus
Sign - Libra - Exaltation Sign - plus
House lagna - favourable - plus
Retrograde - no - plus i will give not retrograde a plus point because it will affect the result in my case.
Conclusion: minus + plus + plus + plus = 2(plus)
Therefore, Saturn in Libra in Lagna is good and it get's 2 positive points.
now do you think Saturn the lagna lord getting exalted in the 10th house can be bad as your method is showing it to be? my method is not only showing it is good but it has also given it 2 plus points.
example 2(your method)
Planet Venus - Natural Benefic - plus
Sign - Taurus - Own Sign - plus
House- 5th house - plus
retrograde - yes - minus
Conclusion: plus x plus x plus x minus = minus
Therefore Venus in the 5th house in Taurus is bad
example 2(my method)
Planet Venus - Natural Benefic - plus
Sign - Taurus - Own Sign - plus
House- 5th house - plus
retrograde - yes - minus
Conclusion: plus + plus + plus + minus = 2(plus)
Therefore Venus in the 5th house in Taurus is good and it get's 2 plus points.
now do you think venus the raja yoga karak planet for the capricon lagna placed in the 5th house will do bad just because it is retrograde as your result is showing? my result is not only showing it is good but giving it 2 plus points.
basab wrote:if just one factor is negative then even if an infinite no. of positive factors be there the result will always be negative because
minus x plus x plus x plus x plus x plus = minus
Can you please provide the link?Ghrishneswar wrote:the best analysis for this has been provided by Visti Larsen on his website srigaruda dot com
[/img]
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest